Credo Beauty Shopping List: My TOP 25 Products to stock up on

UPDATED!
It’s one of the most wonderful times of the year,
the Black Friday of clean beauty…
it’s CREDO’S twice-a-year FRIENDS OF CREDO SALE!

Credo Beauty is a clean beauty superstore…with over 130 brands to choose from, from skincare to makeup to hair and body care, they have everything you need to swap to a cleaner, safer, good-for-you-and-for-the-planet beauty routine. I can purchase almost all of my ride-or-die products from them. Not to mention, Credo is a great resource for clean beauty scoop (I mentioned their Dirty List in my post about switching to clean beauty).

Don’t walk, run, it only happens twice a year, and it’s 20% off most everything at Credo Beauty! I will definitely be stocking up on my staples, along with grabbing a new SPF that’s been raved about recently, and a refillable lipstick from Soshe that I’ve had my eye on (and awaiting a fat sale!) that sounds like it’s right in my wheelhouse…a lipstick balm hybrid.

So without further ado, below you’ll find a quick list of my top 25 products that can be found at Credo Beauty, including a few new loves!

Westman Atelier | Eye Want You Mascara

Westman Atelier’s Eye Want You Mascara gives terrific length AND volume, holds a curl, gives more of the full, feathery look that I like and best of all…NO FLAKING or SMUDGING! Stays on even in crazy humidity, but magically washes off quite easily. I do wish the brush was a bit less big for more control in the inner eye, but that’s my only wee gripe. Outstanding! I will say that I initially put off purchasing it as the price is more than I really like to spend on mascara. But I was desperate, and there was a sale, and now I’m hooked. And while it is on the spendier side, please note that it also has lasted a LOT longer than any tube of clean mascara I’ve ever tried. I’m on month 5 (no judging), and no signs of drying out, etc. Given I would’ve typically gone through 2 tubes in that time, I’m calling it a wash in the budget department. Tied for 1st place in my battle of the top non toxic mascaras!

SWEED | Cloud Mascara

One of my favorite clean beauty finds for 2025! Lots of length, holds curl (though I have to recurl after first coat dries, but I have to do this with almost all mascaras), and lovely fluffy lashes. No flaking! I will say this give me more dramatic lashes then WA does, so it’s great for nighttime events. And like Eye Want You, it comes in black AND brown. IMO the sweet spot for this one is once it’s been open for a bit as it’s a bit wet, but totally worth it, especially given that it’s less expensive then the WA. New favorite non toxic mascara! Tied for 1st in the battle of the best nontoxic mascaras.

Kosas | Wet Stick Moisturizing Lip Shine

I grabbed 2 shades of this newly launched lippie during the Kosas sale, and folks, it was a regular go-to this summer!!! I’d call this a balm-lipstick-gloss hybrid…just the right amount of color, just the right amount of shine, moisturizing and plumping, easy to put swipe on quickly and roll out. 100 Degrees (lovely summer nude) and Sunset Simmer (reminds me of the iconic ‘Toast of NY’ from the 90’s!) are both GORGEOUS.

Kosas | Air Brow Tinted Volumizing Treatment Gel

They call this a ‘Volumizing Treatment Gel’, but it’s definitely got more of a mousse-y texture to it. Full of goodies such as Castor Oil and Panthenol Provitamin B5 to help with growth, but also has Biodegradable Plant-Based Microfibers to help fill in those sparse areas and even everything out. Love everything about this. Color is fab (I used to use Soft Brown but have switched to Taupe as my hair is a bit more highlighted these days), stays on all day, easy to apply and looks natural. AND one tube lasts forever. I’ve not found anything I love for brows as much as this…believe the hype.

Tower28 | Swipe Serum Concealer

Not only does Swipe stay on AND completely cover my redness (broken capillaries around my nose), it goes on so smoothly that it just looks like SKIN. Some kind of magicery! It’s also become my go-to for undereye, but the key is to use much less than you think you need…truly a a-little-goes-a-long-way situation. So natural looking, and great staying power. I was gifted this in the 5.0 shade (thank you T28!), but it’s just a smidge too yellow on me, so I plan to purchase this in the 4.0. Another winner, and current favorite non-toxic concealer! A favorite find in 2025!

Tower28 | BeachPlease Luminous Tinted Balm

My favorite cream blush. Great on cheeks and lips. So far I’ve tried Power Hour, Office Hours and Magic Hour, and all are fab. Magic Hour gets reached for almost daily!

Rituel de Fille | Ash & Ember Eye Soot

Literally the only eye shadow I used last summer, in shade Half Light. It’s THE PERFECT taupe…not too cool, not too warm. If my hoods were puffy, I’d just use a wee bit of it there (applied in a windshield wiper motion with a brush) to create depth and push them back. For a night out I would pat it onto my lids as well, and brush lightly underneath my lower lashline for a lovely subdued smoky-bronze look. Rituel de Fille nails the cream-to-powder genre with their Ash & Ember Eye Soots…great colors, solid staying power, no irritation and keeps my eye area looking smooth instead of crepey.

Ere Perez | Jojoba Eye Pencil

Closest clean dupe for my old favorite liner (Urban Decay). Stone and Bronze are my go-tos, both so pretty. Earth is also a great staple.

RMS Beauty | Legendary Serum Lipstick – The Nudes

This first-of-its-kind lipstick and serum hybrid has been the only lippie I’ve been reaching for this past month! And this range of shades are my JAM. Super lightweight but saturated with color, so easy to swipe on and go (but also great with your fave neutral lip liner). Feels smoothing and somehow cooling on (but no peppermint/menthol). Jayne is FINALLY the perfect nude for me that doesn’t need a liner to adjust the shade, and Mae is a glorious rosewood. SNAG THESE UP!!!

Westman Atelier | Lit Up Highlight Stick in Brûlée

Now is the time to get this. It’s a splurge, but at 20% off you’ve got to grab one. Cheeks, eyes, lips…it does it all. So pretty, just a lovely glow without glitter/shimmer. Credo Beauty is one of only a few that carry this lovely line!

Westman Atelier | Vital Pressed Skincare Powder

Another one to grab on sale as it is sopendy. This gives a PERFECT finish – even on my driest day you wouldn’t guess I had powder on, it just looks so. natural. Takes down any shine from my skincare/SPF/t-zone, smooths the skin not settling into pores and lines, and sets makeup wonderfully prolonging wear. Plus it has skincare benefits!? And all of this while safe for my crazy skin. LOVE. I’ve tried the Translucent, Créme and the Pink Bubble. Translucent is great for me anytime, the Créme being a bit too dark for me until summer…and then it’s going to be PERFECT for giving my skin a tanned effect! The Pink Bubble is AWESOME for brightening me up…just switched to that recently. Several other shades available as well so there’s an option for most skintones.

You don’t need a lot, and it lasts forever, so while it’s on the spendy side, mine has lasted a year. It gets my vote for best non toxic pressed setting powder.

Jenny Patinkin | Vegan Makeup Brush Soap

This lasts forever, and does a great job at cleaning your brushes. All natural and the tin is reusable/recyclable. Great stocking stuffer!

CV Skinlabs | Calming Moisture for Face, Neck & Scalp

Super gentle moisturizer, perfect when your skin is mad at you (sunburn, post-too-much-exfoliating, dermatitis, etc.). Great moisture source for teens as it doesn’t further irritate the acne breakouts. Just a great one to have on hand.

RMS Beauty | ReEvolve Radiance Locking Primer

I’ll be honest, I’ve not had much luck with primers and kind of gave up on them years ago. They’d either not been effective, caused a breakout, were too matte or too shiny…seemed like too much trouble for an additional step in my routine. But the reviews of this REFILLABLE primer were so intriguing, and I’m so damn glad I tried it! It truly locks in the moisture of your skincare (keeping your moisturized but not shiny), creates a smoother canvas for makeup (providing a blurred effect to pores) AND prolongs how long that makeup stays on. I don’t use it everyday, but when I’m going out-and-about in humid weather with makeup on or out at a special event, I use this as my last layer, and it’s made a BIG difference. Love it and will be grabbing my first refill during the sale!

Maya Chia | The Eye Achiever Multi-Correction Eye Serum

One of my favorite clean skincare lines, here’s your chance to score all things Maya Chia! I cheat on this but always come back, because nothing is better. Hydrating but fast-absorbing, lessens those fine lines with no irritation…just totally reliable.

Maya Chia | The Straight A

Ride-or-die, the best plant-based retinol available. Doesn’t irritate my super-sensitive skin. Stock up!!

Maya Chia | The Super Lift Vitamin C-More Treatment

The only Vitamin C serum that doesn’t freak my skin out! And big fat bonus points: it really does have a lovely, immediate firming effect on the skin, plus provides a nice layer of moisture beneath my oil and SPF. And the smell…it’s like walking through an orange grove. I’m forever your girl, Maya Chia. One of my favorite finds for Best of 2021 and still in regular rotation!

Marie Veronique | Barrier Restore Serum

Have I mentioned that Marie Veronique’s line completely saved my skin from perioral dermatitis? This is one of those products that I get really antsy about getting low, because it literally stops a PD break-out in its tracks when I see it coming on. Absolutely phenomenal at re-balancing barrier function. Magic in a bottle. It’s spendy so I do wait for sales, and when I stock up I also grab some Barrier Lipid Complex and Pre + Probiotic Daily Mist (I know, I’m kind of cheating here, but it’s another favorite skin-saving line, and folks, winter is coming!!!).

Kosas | DreamBeam SPF 40 PA++++

Here’s your chance to save again on this fabulous new sunscreen! I’ve been using it for over a year now, and absolutely loving it! No reactions, feels great on, plays nicely with my other products, and I LOVE that it’s got a bit higher SPF than your typical daily sunscreens. Don’t let the ‘tint’ fool you though…the slight beige-y/apricot hue just takes away the issue of whitecast, but doesn’t provide any sort of coverage. A new favorite sunscreen for sensitive skin!!

Tower28 | SOS Daily Rescue Facial Spray

The glowing reviews are all well-deserved as this mist is something special. If you have any type of skin sensitivity, jump on this. You’ll see redness start to dissipate IMMEDIATELY (including “redness” from too much sun *oops*). When my skin is acting up I spray this on and let it dry while I get dressed, before I begin layering on my other products. I’ve been loving it for 2 years (it was one of my top picks in clean beauty for 2021), one of my favorite products for battling perioral dermatitis and definitely a must for sensitive skin.

Osea | Undaria Algae Oil

One of my favorite body oils, sinks in and seals in the moisture after a shower. Smells so good!

NÉCESSAIRE | The Deodorant

Another one of my favorite finds for last year! The key ingredient for keeping stink away is the Mandelic Acid which also helps with discoloration and smoothness, and absolutely love that it also has niacinamide to protect that skin barrier. Genuinely keeps odor away all day, no irritation. The Olibanum scent is gorgeous, warm and cozy, and went so well with all of my fall/winter fragrances; I’ve just switched to the Eucalyptus scent and it’s just as lovely, plus also gives a bit of a cooling sensation (which is perfect for those of us enjoying the hot flashes of it all…)!

Innersense | I Create Volume

A sale is the perfect time to build up your product stash, and this one is a staple for me. I’m so glad my stylist turned me on to it. I’d previously passed it by as ‘lotions’ typically weigh my curls down, but this is actually a lightweight liquid gel! I couldn’t get the I Create Hold gel to work for me fine 3B curls, but this stuff is fantastic.

Innersense | Inner Peace Whipped Creme Texturizer

Again thankful for my stylist. I’d bought this a while back but just couldn’t get it to work in my routine. She showed me that it works beautifully for SOTC (scrunch out the crunch)! Plus gives some volume. Just a weeee bit is needed, so tub will last forever!

So many items to choose from, but these are my best-of-the-best that can be found at Credo Beauty. Comment below with any questions. Now get to shopping before things sell out. Let me know what you get!